Mark
12:28-34
We're
on a journey through holy week, which is of course the last and most
important week in the life of Jesus as told in the gospel of Mark.
It's a rather long story, so it's rather hard to get in on Palm Sunday,
there's just too much there. And so we often don't look at that
story as a whole. So part of what I'm trying to do during Lent is
rather than focus on the journey to Jerusalem as traditionally we've
often done in the Lent season, is to focus on just that week
itself. Taking one day of the week on each Sunday and help us to
more appreciate the totality of it then when we actually arrive at holy
week.
And so I began last
Sunday with Monday of holy week, when Jesus cursed the fig tree and then
symbolically shut down the temple, in that story we often refer to
(although not very accurately) as the "cleansing" of the
temple.
And now we come to
Tuesday, which is the longest day in Mark's story of holy week. It
has 8 different incidents in it, teachings and stories, 115 verses that
goes from Chapter 11 verse 20 all the way through Chapter 13 in what's
known as the 'little apocalypse', when Jesus talks about the destruction
of the temple at the end days. And so there's way too much there
on Tuesday to even cover in 1 sermon.
But I want to give a
quick sketch of the most essential parts of that as it relates to the
text that I'm going to read in a moment. And hone in on that
central and I think very pivotal passage that is not only pivotal to the
holy week story, it is pivotal to the gospel as a whole.
The day begins when
Jesus and his disciples arrive into the city, and not surprisingly, they
come into the city by the same path which they've always come -- they go
out of the city each night, and come back the same way. So,
therefore, they come walking by that very same tree that Jesus cursed on
Monday morning, what we
talked about last Sunday. And Peter, acting quite surprised,
looks that the tree and says 'Look at that! Golly, gee whiz, the
tree is withered!' They've been with Jesus through a lot -- they
have seen Jesus walk on water, they've seen him heal the sick, feed the
5,000, heal the blind not once but twice, raise people from the
dead. You would think that by now they would have gotten used to
the fact that Jesus can do all kinds of miraculous things. But no,
instead, Peter seems totally amazed. Which is again the storyteller at work, as we have been focusing on.
This amazement of
Peter is really not about the fig tree at all. Nor is it even
about the wondrous powers of Jesus. So, remember if you were here
last week, when I said the first key to understanding this story is
understanding Mark as a storyteller. When Matthew tells this very
same story of the fig tree, there's no night in-between. In
Matthew's story, it's simply: Jesus curses the fig tree and bam!
it withers up and dies. When Mark tells the story, Jesus curses
the tree, goes into the temple, shuts the temple down (creates the mess
there), goes back out of the city, comes back the next day, THEN we
discover that the tree has withered and died. In other words, Mark
understands the element of suspense. And he wants us to be sure
that we get that point -- that the tree is a symbol of the temple.
So that when Peter cries out 'O gosh look what's happened to the tree!',
Mark wants to make sure that WE see the tree. It's not about the
other disciples seeing the tree, it's about us seeing the tree,
and that we get the point. A tree without fruit is like a temple
without justice.
So get over your
hang-ups over this odd story about the tree, you know, the poor tree
that suffered unjustly at the whim of Jesus. It's not about the
tree, it's about the church, and the temple. So we move on.
Jesus talks about the
power of faith and prayer, and then he comes once again into the
temple. And as soon as he comes into the temple on Tuesday
morning, immediately, he's questioned. He's challenged. The
authorities are on him. They've got a whole bunch of questions
they want to ask. First of all, 'who gave you the right, by what
authority are you doing these things? Show us your credentials,
that you are entitled to come into the temple, create this mess (didn't
stick around to clean it up, left us with it)', etc. And so they
began grilling him. They're not very happy. So you have to
keep in mind the context of what happened on the day before to
understand the questions they put to Jesus.
And so their first
question: "By what authority do you do these
things?" And Jesus stumps them with a question of his own,
also about authority -- sort of "I'll answer your question if you
answer mine". And he asked them: 'Was the baptism of
John from God or was it something that John just made up?' And
they think to themselves -- if they say it's from God, he'll say then
how come you're not doing the things that John told you to do? And
if they say it's by human authority, the people will get upset with
them, they'll lose credibility in their sight, because John is very
popular. So they decline to answer the question. And so
Jesus declines to answer theirs.
Then they ask a
second question, since Jesus kind of got them with a trick question,
they try to get Jesus with a trick question: "Is it lawful to
pay taxes to Caesar?" Now the trick is, if you say 'yes' to
that, you will lose credibility with the people, it's very unpopular [to
pay taxes], same then as it is today. And if you say no to it,
they can say 'Aha!, he is advocating tax resistance, that's the crime of
sedition, he can be thrown into jail'. So it's a no-win question.
Jesus
doesn't answer the question. Instead, he asks for a coin, a
denarius, and they give him one. Now that's a very curious thing
in and of itself. The Roman coins, denarius, has the image of
Caesar on it, as we know (because we have many of these coins, they've
been found), and it has typically an inscription. It says Caesar
Divi Filius in Latin. Caesar, Son of God. And you see that's
precisely why Jews were not allowed to bring that coin into the temple
because of its graven image. And that's why, therefore, the tables
for the money changers -- so they could exchange their money and not
bring that coin in.
Now what's
interesting, of course, Jesus is in the temple. He asks for a
coin. Who has one? The religious leaders. Carrying the
very coin that they're not supposed to have in the temple! So he
gets them right off the bat there, and asks who's image is on it?
Well, Caesar's. So, the famous saying "Give unto Caesar what
is Caesar's, give to God what is God's".
Now if you have
understood that to mean to pay our taxes as we pay our tithes to the
church, you've totally missed the point. If Jesus wants to support
paying the taxes, all he had to do was answer 'yes', that it's lawful to
pay taxes to Caesar. But you see, the whole point of his response
is to refute the assumption of the question that is based on the
temple's collaboration with Rome. Once you start asking this
question -- what belongs to Caesar, and what belongs to God? Does
this fruit from my harvest belong to Caesar or to God? -- well, of
course, it's God. Do the things in my life belong to Caesar or to
God? Of course, God. What belongs to Caesar? When you
begin to ask that question, Caesar is going to lose every time.
Because it all belongs to God. The fullness of the earth and all
that is therein belongs to God.
And then we come
finally to the third question, asked by the Sadducees, a religious party
that does not believe in the resurrection of the dead, and they try to
trick Jesus with their own trick question about life after death (which
they don't even believe in). They use a question to show that it's
a nonsensical notion: if a woman has 7 different husbands, because
each one dies and she marries another, who's she going to be married to in
the next life? And Jesus once again refuses the rationale of the
question and challenges the assumption behind it, affirming that God is
the God of the living and not of the dead.
Now after these 3
hostile questions comes what appears to be an honest question with no
hidden motive behind it. A scribe, one of the religious leaders of
the temple, apparently breaks ranks with his leadership, impressed by
the answers Jesus gives to the other questions, decides to ask one of
his own. And this then is the central section in Tuesday, comes
right in the middle of these 115 verses, and pivotal to the
gospel. So listen carefully then to Mark 12:28-34:
28 One
of the scribes came near and heard them disputing with one another,
and seeing that he answered them well, he asked him, ‘Which
commandment is the first of all?’ 29Jesus
answered, ‘The first is, “Hear, O Israel: the Lord our God,
the Lord is one; 30you shall love the Lord your
God with all your heart, and with all your soul, and with all your
mind, and with all your strength.” 31The
second is this, “You shall love your neighbour as yourself.” There
is no other commandment greater than these.’ 32Then
the scribe said to him, ‘You are right, Teacher; you have truly said
that “he is one, and besides him there is no other”; 33and
“to love him with all the heart, and with all the understanding, and
with all the strength”, and “to love one’s neighbour as
oneself”,—this is much more important than all whole
burnt-offerings and sacrifices.’ 34When Jesus
saw that he answered wisely, he said to him, ‘You are not far from
the kingdom of God.’ After that no one dared to ask him any
question.
And so you see it
builds up to that point with this series of questions and the hostility,
and finally we get to the essence of it -- the greatest commandment of
all.
It's not surprising
that a scribe would ask this question. There's a long tradition
behind the question, in fact. There are 613 laws in the Torah, in
the Hebrew scripture, and 365 of those are prohibitions. One
"thou shalt not" for every day of the year. And 248
affirmations, which corresponds to something you should do literally for
every bone in your body. The numbers may not be coincidental
there. And so many Jewish leaders over the years have tried to
boil that down to the essence. In Psalm 15, we read 11 essential
commandments. The prophet Micah (in 6:8) narrows it down to
three: do justice, love kindness, walk humbly with your God.
The prophet Amos also narrows it down to three: hate evil, love
good, do justice.
A great story of two
famous Rabbi's in the first century, about the same time of Jesus (a
little bit after), who were asked by a Gentile if they could teach him
the totality of the Torah while standing on one leg. So you kind
of get this image -- how long can you stand on one leg? And one of
the Rabbi's, Shammai, was so offended by the trivial nature of the
question that he chased the questioner out with a stick. The other
Rabbi, Hillel, who is also mentioned in the New Testament, instead
responds with a negative form of the golden rule: "Do not do
to others what you would not do to yourself. That is Torah, all
else is commentary on it".
After church I'd
invite you to come up and look at the symbols of the various religions
left here from the interfaith service last night, and see if you can
spot other forms of the golden rule. I think about 4 of them have
various forms of the golden rule, and there are more than that -- almost
every religious tradition has some expression of the golden rule:
Do unto others as you would do unto yourself.
So, what is most
important? What is most basic to God's commands? If you boil
it down to its most elemental essence, what do you have? It's
an honest question. It's a question many people have today.
And the answer that Jesus gives is thoroughly, through and through,
Jewish. First he recites the shamah -- shamah is the first Hebrew
word: "O Hear". O Hear, Israel, the Lord your God
is one. And that verse, from Deuteronomy 6, is so central to the
Jewish faith, it is still put on the doorframes of every Jewish home to
this day. Just last Monday night, Judy and I were at the home of
Rabbi Husbands-Hankin for dinner, and sure enough it was right there on
the doorpost as we entered in, the shamah.
And it continues,
then: love the Lord your God with all your heart, with all your
soul, with all your strength. And to that trio, Mark adds Jesus
saying also love the Lord your God with all your mind. And then
Jesus goes on to quote from Leviticus 19 the second commandment, to love
your neighbor as yourself. Two sides of one coin.
And the scribe
responds here, very interesting, by affirming Jesus. It's the
scribe who pronounces on Jesus, 'yeah, this is right, this is
true'. And he summarizes, repeats what he has heard from Jesus,
showing that he gets it. And making sure that we do to. And
as an illustration of how central this is to the Christian faith, I
would refer you to Paul, where he echoes this very same sentiment in
Romans 13 and says "Owe no one anything,
except to love one another; for the one who loves another has fulfilled
the law." Then he goes on to cite four of the
commandments -- you shall not commit adultery, murder, you shall not
steal or covet. And says "and any other commandment, are
summed up in this word, ‘Love your neighbor as
yourself.’"
And then in 1 John we
read: "Whoever does not love does not
know God, for God is love." And I noticed that was the
verse they chose to represent Christianity on that collection of
[interfaith] symbols.
So this is the
essence of the gospel. This is what Jesus came to show us how to
do.
Now, since I've
mentioned the interfaith service, last night at the service that was
gathered here (a full house), a couple of young men came into the
service, looked around, decided it wasn't for them, left very loudly,
showing great disrespect for the service in progress. And swung on
the door, the exterior door (not sure if any of you noticed when you
came in, the repair work done on that door late last night), swung on
that door, hanging on it when they went out, yanking it out of its
hinges. Pulling it apart, separating the door and it fell with a
big crash onto the porch, broke the stained-glass window and then they
ran off laughing.
When I came out and
saw the damage to the door, I was just livid. And my first
response was 'I want to grab these guys, I want to strip them naked, I
want to hand them up by their . . . . big toes. . . . by the columns of
the church in public shame for everyone to see' J.
And then I remembered those 9 churches in Alabama and Mississippi that
were burned to the ground in several cases. They caught two
college students responsible for this -- started out as a prank, then
they had to continue it to cover up their tracks. Faith
communities have lost everything. And the pastor of one of those
churches, I cited a couple weeks ago, he said "We will pray for the
perpetrators, and if given the opportunity we will forgive
them".
And I felt ashamed in
my response. I thought, yes, I will pray for them. I will
love them. I will forgive them. And then I will strip
them naked and hang them up by the columns! But at least they'll
be forgiven while they're up there J.
As I told a couple of
the folks last night -- maybe it's not a bad thing for them to rip the
doors off the church, because we should have an open door. We
should be every night what we were last night. As Jesus said last
Sunday, this is a house of prayer for all people.
Well, there's a bit
of surprise in this text, when Jesus affirms this religious leader of
the temple. And I think that's an important reminder for us, that
they were not all bad folk. Did you catch the story this week,
that members of the Christian Broadcasting Network voted Pat Robertson
off the board? They're not all bad folk, there's some good ones in
there, it just takes a few bad apples to make the rest look bad.
So we should
remember, a good portion -- maybe the majority -- of the leadership of
the temple were good, decent, devout people of faith. And so Jesus
says to this one scribe: "You are not far from the realm (or
the Kingdom) of God". In other words, to love God and
neighbor is to be near that realm of God. And by implication then,
the more we love God, the more we love our neighbors, the closer we draw
to the realm of God.
Moses Mendelson tells
the story of a woman who came to a great teacher and asked him:
"Teacher, how do I know which religion is the right
one?" And he replied with a story of a great and wise King
with 3 sons and a precious gift -- a magic ring that gave him great
compassion, generosity, and a spirit of kindness. And as he was
dying, each of those sons went to him individually and asked the father
for the ring after his death. And he promised to each that he
would give them the ring. And before he died he called in the
finest jewelry maker of the land and asked him to make two identical
copies of the ring. So that after his death each of his sons was
presented with the ring. Well, it wasn't long before they figured
out that the other brothers all had a ring and therefore two of them had
to be fakes, and only one of them could be the genuine article.
And so they went before a judge and asked the judge to help them
determine which was the authentic ring and then they could determine who
the proper heir was. The judge could not distinguish between the
three. And so he said: we shall watch and see which son
behaves in the most gracious, generous, and kind manner. Then we
will know which possesses the original ring.
And from that day on,
each son lived as if he was the one with the magic ring, and no one
could tell which was the most gracious, generous, and kind. And so
the teacher said, if you wish to know which religion is true, watch and
see which reveals God's love for the world.
Are we going to do
that? Will others do that?
Tuesday begins with
the cursed, withered tree, and ends with Jesus reflecting in chapter 13
on the eventual destruction of the temple. In-between the cursed
tree and the destroyed temple comes the great commandment: to love
God with all your heart, soul, mind, and strength, and to love your
neighbor as yourself.
Show that love.
Practice that love. Live that love every day and with
everyone. And you will be ever near to the way God wants this
world to be. That is the law of God, and all else is commentary
upon it.